the great organic con.

I’m in the process of searching for a course to help me become a better gardener.

I enrolled in horticulture at Wodonga a couple of years ago and didn’t find it to my liking.

I didn’t like the focus on chemical remedies and there were a number of other philosophical differences between that and the way I like to do things.

When I discovered a permaculture course at Thurgoona TAFE I was quite excited, my excitement was short lived however as I found the course seemed to be heavily involved in the organic food movement which I have serious reservations about.

I prefer not to use chemicals, I doubt anyone would call me a chemically reliant gardener, I have lost stuff rather than spray, I prefer a “soil up” approach, meaning that I see it as priority 1 to enrich the soil and it’s resident flora and fauna.

To me these things aren’t revolutionary, they are good practice and most importantly they work.

To my great chagrin I discovered the focus of the course I was looking at was on commercial organic production, a scam if ever I have seen one.

A quick review of the “organic” movement will show you that it was “invented” by a couple of rich aristocracy types in Britain during the middle of last century.

Indeed “bonnie” Prince Charles has just celebrated 25 years of “organic gardening” in one of his country estates.

Which is really my main criticism of it, it’s elitist, a form of food snobbery really.

Organic METHODS work exceedingly well, in fact they are unsurpassed in my opinion, the problem is that the TERM “organic” seems to have been subverted and there is immense pressure for people who use these methods of food production to become “licenced” or “accredited”.

In effect the term “organic” (really a meaningless buzz-word, what does an IN-organic apple taste like I wonder?) has been subverted by those who stand to make a quick buck from regulating it and sold of as a commodity for profit.

Another way for money to run uphill in other words.

If anyone who produces food for either their or someone else’s consumption chooses to use chemicals in their production, they have little choice but to have some multi-national like Monsanto dipping into their pocket.

Genetic modification seems set to compound this problem massively.

However if a food producer chooses to advertise that they do NOT use chemicals in their processes, they have a completely separate group sticking their hand in their pocket by way of organic “accreditation” which can run to multiple hundreds of dollars per year.

For a small operator, this is nothing short of crippling.

Ever wondered WHY you pay between two to five times MORE for produce grown without chemicals and grown locally than for equivalent grown far away and WITH chemicals?

I know I have.

Well the answer is that all that “accrediting” BS has to be payed for, in the short term it’s the poor beggar scratching a living off the soil who picks up the can.

Longer term, if he or she wants to stay afloat, they have little or no choice but to pass on the cost to the consumers of their produce.

The process of “organic accreditation” came about in response to people claiming their produce was grown pesticide and herbicide free, and the claims turned out to be spurious.

The solution?

A heavy handed, over regulated, top heavy industry which can’t compete on an even footing because it is hamstrung by maintaining the cost of the bureaucracy that feeds on it.

A veritable plague of $75KPA+ “locusts” which in all likely hood wont stop devouring until there is nothing left.

As with so many things when you decide not to use chemicals, the “cure” is worse than the ailment.

Anyway, nobody’s going to tell me how to grow things and if I choose not to use chemicals that’s my buisiness.

As for “organic accreditation/ certification” well I guess it would make good fertiliser (if you can stand the stench).

My solution? grow your own and put the whole filthy lot of them out of buisiness as quickly as possible.


About alburywodongaonline

Hi I'm Jack Stone (a pseudonym), I'm a long-time Albury resident and I think it's a great place to live and work. I have a strong interest in local events and media and I started this site because I think a different perspective is often needed when reporting local news. I take a keen interest in local politics, as well as what's going on at the state and federal level, I'm also a supporter of social justice issues, the envirionment and the need for people to have a say in the events that effect their lives. I'm a fan of the Border Bandits and I'd love to see both teams take the flag this year, and next year, and maybe the one after that too.
This entry was posted in Agriculture, Current Events, Editorial, Environment, Gardening, Lifestyle. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to the great organic con.

  1. Greg Naylor says:

    Jack, you are on the right track. I say we need a new movement called “Home Grown” which positively targets the use of anything commercial whether it be seed / plant stock, fertilisers, insectices etc.

    There is nothing nicer than enjoying “Home Grown” eggs from the chooks, the chooks themselves and the fruit and vegetables home grown at my place.

    They say you are what you eat and I chose to eat my home grown produce

  2. jr says:

    If only you could nurture your vegies with all that BS, Jack. 😉

  3. Kieran says:

    Growing your own food in your own home is one of the most positive things an individual can do to reduce their impact re climate change and the environment.

    I’m looking forward to harvesting my first tomatoes soon, the peas are nearly at an end, the beans didn’t come to much, the pumpkins are all coming along nicely, and I am never going to run out of potatoes or onions.

  4. JR, I find horse manure is a lot cheaper (and easier to come by) than the bovine equivalent.

    I’ve actually found a trainer who regularly feeds his horses comfrey and doesn’t use much in the way of chemical treatments on them.

    Needless to say it’s the best manure going (and I got dibs!!)

    Kieran nice to see you back!!
    Good luck with the pumpkins, I found my dirt needs a LOT of work before I’m ready to grow agricultural show winning pumpkins.

    Greg, we may miss one another as I’m leaving town on Christmas eve but I’ll be in touch and if you don’t mind I can leave a partially filled water tray out in the shade for the seedlings.

    I’ll call you before then anyway and we can work something out.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s